Industry Blog

Uni-Dust Cyclone Case Study


Introduction

A major pharmaceutical company was losing powder from tablet presses and capsule filling machines. This caused a dangerous cocktail of powders to form in the central dust extraction system and was also blocking the expensive HEPA filter at the heart of this system. Having heard of the cyclone, they approached Hanningfield to learn if the innovative dust containment system could benefit them - it could.

 

Our Solution

The cyclone was initially trialled by attaching it to a capsule filling machine, to analyse the effectiveness of the cyclone in capturing a standard pharmaceutical powder - the results were staggering. The filterless cyclone was able to capture over 95% of all excess powder, which is collected in a ‘catch-pot’ at the bottom of the cyclone. This allows the contents to be weighed for batch loss reconciliation, which is excellent for FDA compliance.

The real monetary saving, however, was in protecting the central HEPA filter. Each cyclone has an individual “police” HEPA filter which increases system efficiency to 99.99%, allowing the clean air to flow to the normal dust extraction unit.

As the equipment is designed to be retrofitted to any dust generating plant, process validation is not affected, making it ideal for both new and existing processes.

 

Results and Conclusions

The cyclone was an undoubted success and helped protect the main filter from continual blockage. This was very expensive to replace but required changing every 6
months due to the extreme wear and tear. The cyclone system has saved the central filter to make replacement much more infrequent, saving vast amounts of money and offering an incredible return on investment.

The system also helps protects operators by capturing excess dust in the process room, preventing the formation of a dangerous mix of powders. The customer was extremely pleased with the cyclone and now has more than 40 units installed worldwide.

 

Key Facts

- Capture Over 95% of Excess Dust: The Hanningfield cyclone is capable of capturing most of the dust lost during processing. For this case study, the customer was able to capture and collect over 95% of all powder. In-house trials have achieved results of up to 99.99% efficiency on a pharmaceutical powder.

- Protect Central Dust Extraction: By protecting the central dust extraction system, the customer made vast savings in time, money and improved hygiene, simply by installing the cyclone to their capsule filling machines and tablet presses. This ensured an excellent return on investment (ROI) by protecting the expensive filters in the central dust extraction system.

- Keep Operators Safe: By preventing a dangerous cocktail of powders from forming in the central dust extraction system, operators are kept safe. Instead, dangerous powders are captured in a ‘catch-pot’.

- Comply with FDA Guidelines: Comply with FDA Guidelines; By capturing excess dust in a ‘catch-pot’ the customer was able to undertake batch loss reconciliation, to account for the losses in processing. This is excellent practice and ensures compliance with FDA guidelines.

For more information on the Uni-Dust cyclone, please click here.

Hanningfield Advert in Pharmaceutical Processing Magazine (September 2011)

With over 20 years experience in pharmaceutical processing, Hanningfield are one of the more established suppliers of process equipment to the pharmaceutical industry.

To emphasise our position in the market, Hanningfield are committed to reaffirming our reputation through our affiliation with the most credible and well-known publications in the pharmaceutical processing industry. Most recently, we featured in the September issue of Pharmaceutical Processing magazine with a full page advert.

To see the advert either click here, or simply click the thumbnail image below.

IBC Loading using Vacuum Transfer

There are various methods for loading material into an IBC or bulk container. One of the most efficient and cost effective methods is the use of a well designed vacuum transfer system.

Vacuum transfer into an IBC offers a reliable dust-tight transfer that is highly flexible and easily adapted to various process changes. Using vacuum transfer is an ideal material handling solution where there is restricted space above the IBC. Even in tight spaces, loading rates of 1,000 kg per hour are often possible.

“Vacuum transfer is a simple, fully-contained method for loading an IBC”

To ensure the best possible powder transfer from the vacuum transfer hopper into the IBC, a dust-tight seal is essential. This can take the form of a dust cap, flexible silicone sleeve, inflatable sealing system or a split butterfly docking system, to give the highest level of integrity. It is worth remembering that it is essential to vent the IBC or receiving container, in order r to disperse displaced air during filling. This is easily done using a vent filter. Vent filters can be simple fabric sock-type filters or miniature HEPA filters.

Material pick-up can be achieved in a variety of ways. The most common method is of material pick-up is using a hand held vacuum wand. To minimise any dust concerns during this process a localised dust extract system can be used. Alternatively a Sack-Tip Station or feed bin provides a semi-automated method of material pick-up. These systems can incorporate a dust-hood and integrated or external dust extraction to further help improve containment. Finally, powder can be drawn straight from the outlet of one IBC and transferred to another.

One major advantage is that other processes such as sieving or milling can be performed ‘in-line’. This helps reduce operator exposure and eliminates the need for a separate process step providing a major cost benefit. From pick-up point to discharge a fully contained system helps protect both the environment and personnel from the hazards of airborne dust particles.

Using vacuum transfer, processes such as milling and sieving can be performed ‘in-line’.

Improved containment using vacuum transfer for IBC loading also means reduced waste which further contributes to overall cost savings. Taking into consideration the benefits of flexibility, containment, labour savings and ease of cleaning, vacuum transfer for the loading of IBC’s and other bulk containers is the normally the optimal solution.

For more information on Hanningfield’s vacuum transfer systems, please click here, or click the link below.

 

Reclaiming Tablets

Some manufactured tablets may be off-specification. However, even when a tablet fails final inspection, all may not be lost. Rather than discard the tablets, they can be reclaimed by milling the tablet back down to its powdered form. The product can then be re-worked for process re-introduction, significantly helping reduce waste and increase productivity.

Off-spec tablets can be safely milled for process re-introduction

Typical causes of off-specification tablets are; over-weight or under-weight, poor appearance, incorrect hardness and incorrect packaging. In fact, any condition which threatens to scrap a batch of valuable finished goods can be saved by using a conical screen mill to overcome the problem.

The hygienic and highly flexible design of the Uni-Mill is ideal for sanitary applications and a fully validated mill is the perfect way to ensure product integrity is maintained. It is possible to employ the same machine used for size reduction of pre-compression material as for the reclaim process. This provides a very cost effective solution for both the production of new material as well as re-worked material all performed on one machine.

Cone mills are a hygienic method of size reduction

A wide range of interchangeable tooling can be supplied with the Uni-Mill conical screen mill and special tooling can be used for particularly hard tablets. Tooling is also available to mill filled capsules. Hard Shell capsules can be loaded into the mill in the normal way and the capsules are then shredded and torn away from the contents. The resulting mix of broken capsules and powders can then be sieved to ensure the final powder is fully separated and can be safely re-used as required.

As production costs continue to rise, the case for reclaiming off-specification products gets increasingly stronger. Hanningfield is able to provide appropriate cost-effective solutions to make this process a viable and practical option.

 

Conveying of Tablets and Capsules

Overcoming the Problems of Tablet and Capsule Transfer

It is commonly acknowledged that extreme care must be taken when attempting to transport tablets and capsules from one process to another by whatever means used. The fragile nature or these products means damage can easily occur during the transport stage thus potentially wasting valuable finished goods.

Tablet and capsule handling systems must be carefully designed to avoid damage or breakages

Popular methods used for the transfer of these products are vacuum, gravity, and air all of which are standard practice within the pharmaceutical and associated industries. Hanningfield can offer much experience in this area but several points must be taken into consideration to achieve efficient material handling without damage to the finished product.

 

Design

Special attention has to be taken regarding design and construction materials to avoid damage to the finished product. Using specially developed design techniques it is possible to adapt standard Hanningfield process equipment to suit this highly specialised yet popular application.

For example, removable silicone liners can be supplied to fit inside vacuum transfer hoppers to avoid contact between the tablet and any metal surfaces. Specially designed air flow control valves can also be fitted to ensure when vacuum conveying of tablets, they can only move in one direction during vertical transfer cycles.

 

Methods

Vacuum Transfer is a well established process that can be adapted to efficiently convey coated and uncoated tablets very successfully. Internal surfaces must be specially designed to ensure the tablets do not come into contact with sharp edges or corners during transfer (‘step-less conveying’). Other precautions are taken to ensure tablets will only move in one direction during transfer by use of a specially design uni-directional flow valve. The Hanningfield uni-vac system offers a number of enhanced capabilities that combine to provide safe effective tablet transfer without compromising the finished product.

Gravity is the simplest and most common transfer technique for the efficient transfer of tablets and capsules. This process is however limited to a vertical or near vertical flow path only, whereas vacuum and air powered systems can transport across horizontal distances as well as vertically upwards. To control tablet transfer, Hanningfield can supply a special flexible vane butterfly valve to minimise risk of damage when opening and closing the valve.

Air (positive pressure) is used by Hanningfield for the efficient transfer of both empty and filled hard shell capsules. Capsules are less likely to suffer from damage than tablets during conveying but internal conveying pipes must be smooth bore without ledges and sharp corners as with vacuum conveying. The positive pressure system provides a high flow, low pressure air cushion that gently moves the capsules through the convey pipe-work. Static is a common problem with capsule transfer so any system design for this application must provide an anti-static design.

 

Summary

In addition to good and efficient design, experience is also necessary to ensure all aspects of product protection are taken care of. This is where Hanningfield can provide the necessary input at the system concept stage to ensure a successful project conclusion using our highly skilled team of experienced engineers to guide the customer every step of the way.

Hanningfield in EPM Magazine (March/April 2011)

Hanningfield are pleased to feature in this month’s EPM (European Pharmaceutical Manufacturer) Magazine with an article on Page 33, entitled ‘Understanding ATEX Milling’.  You can read the article by clicking on the thumbnail image below, or alternatively, you can read the article below..

For more information on Hanningfield’s milling systems, click here.  Or to contact us, click here.


Help with Understanding ATEX Milling Offered by Hanningfield

The risk of explosion in pharmaceutical manufacturing facilities is a real possibility. To eliminate this risk, conformity and compliance with ATEX safety legislation is compulsory. Typical process areas with high risk of explosion are granulation, mixing and vacuum conveying. ATEX is the harmonised European standard created to ensure all equipment located in environments meet the specifications of the directive in terms of safety. There are currently two European directives in existence; 94/9/EC, which is principally for manufacturers and 99/92/EC, for operators of the equipment.

Previous legislation for controlling explosive atmospheres has only been concerned with electrical equipment. The current ATEX directives now include hazards from mechanical sources, such as mills. A seized bearing or mechanical failure which causes excessive heat to be generated is considered as likely to cause an explosion as an electrical fault. This is now considered to be equally important in the design and use of pharmaceutical equipment, such as mills, for powder processing.

To comply with ATEX standards a number of safety measures must be taken to eliminate any potential risk. This is initially carried out by the customer on the product to be milled via a risk analysis (Ignition Hazard Assessment), which will also evaluate the environment in which the size reduction process will take place. This assessment will determine type of hazardous zoning required inside and outside of the mill. Using the information provided, the mill supplier can then design the equipment to meet the appropriate ATEX Directive measures. The mill supplier is also responsible to advise the user of any precautions necessary to operate the mill safely.

It is imperative to match the equipment in use to the location itself when positioning equipment which is either situated in an ATEX zoned environment or contains an explosive atmosphere. If the equipment is situated in an ATEX zoned area then the external features of the mill must comply with the ATEX provisions according to the zone. Necessary precautions should be taken relating to the effect on the surrounding area and also effects resulting from the surrounding area.

With many years experience of designing and supplying explosion category milling equipment, the Hanningfield ‘Uni-Mill’ provides the ideal solution to meet ATEX legislation directives specifically for the pharmaceutical environment. Special features such as continuous earth design, temperature monitoring and nitrogen purging ensure appropriate compliance measures are in place for every machine supplied to meet the level of hazard specified.

Although ATEX legislation appears to be quite complex, with proper consultation between user and supplier, a safe system that meets the requirements of ATEX can be fully complied with - Hanningfield is happy to help with this.

Gaining Flexibility in Milling Systems

Hanningfield cone mills can offer excellent versatility for engineers and operators alike.

Often, over time, what a customer needs from a piece of machinery may change. This can be extremely true of size reduction mills, such as cone mills. Perhaps the mill needs to be used in another room, at a different operating height or even for a new purpose.

To overcome this problem, it is often advisable to keep the initial mill design as flexible as possible - to ‘future-proof’ against changes to the procedure, the process environment or the product itself.

In this respect, the Hanningfield ‘Uni-Mill’ cone mill can offer a number of significant advantages, in terms of product design. As well as a standard ‘machine-only’ design, Hanningfield are able to incorporate a mobile frame, a height-adjustable hoist, or both, to offer the ultimate in flexible milling systems.

 

Mobile Systems

The Hanningfield Uni-Mill cone mill is extremely compact and is available on a mobile frame. The mobile frame incorporates anti-static, non-marking castors, which allow the machine to be moved within a process room, or even to another room for processing of a different type of product.

Cone mills can easily be fitted to a mobile frame

This can also be particularly advantageous for cleaning and maintenance, as this can be performed away from the process room itself, ensuring the room is not ‘out-of-bounds’, allowing processing/manufacturing to continue whilst the cone mill is being cleaned.

 

Height Adjustable Systems

By mounting the mill on a hoist, a customer can gain height adjustability for vertical positioning of the cone mill. This allows the mill to be raised, or lowered, according to the needs of the process.

Mounting a cone mill onto a post hoist is a simple way of gaining height adjustability

Raising a mill; for example, a customer may wish to raise the mill above an IBC, for milling directly into the inlet of the IBC.

Lowering a mill; for example, the customer may wish to lower the mill to position the mill underneath the outlet of an IBC/vacuum hopper, so product can be directly discharged into the inlet of the mill.

This sort of height adjustability can offer great process flexibility from ‘Day One’, but can also offer long-term benefits in terms of making the cone mill adaptable to undertake a variety of different functions.

 

Changing Screen and Impeller

When considering the flexibility of any type of mill, it is always important to consider tooling changes - such as how much variation does the tooling offer? Or how quick and easy are tooling changes?

Changing the screen and impeller on a cone mill is quick and easy

A cone mill uses a screen and impeller, both of which offer excellent flexibility. Different screens and impellers allow different types of products to be milled, and different particle sizes to be achieved with great easy. Importantly, tooling changes are simple and fast, taking only a couple of minutes to change both screen and impeller.

GMP (Good Manufacturing Practice) Explained

A Technical Article by Colin Ellis (Managing Director, Hanningfield)


What is GMP?

GMP or ‘Good Manufacturing Practice’ is the area of quality assurance which ensures that medicinal (and some food) products are consistently produced and controlled to the quality standards appropriate for their intended use and as required by the product specification. In this respect, GMP is concerned with both quality control and production.

“The FDA inspects manufacturing facilities worldwide using scientifically and cGMP-trained individuals whose job it is to evaluate whether the company is following the cGMP regulations.” GMP regulations are enforceable by law and require that manufacturers, processors, and packagers of pharmaceuticals, medical devices, and some types of food products take proactive steps to ensure that their products are pure, effective and safe to use.

"The FDA ensures cGMP standards are upheld."

GMP regulations address all issues that concern record keeping, hygiene, personnel qualifications, cleanliness, equipment verification and the handling of complaints. These regulations in turn protect the consumer from purchasing a product which is ineffective or potentially life threatening. Failure of manufacturers to comply with GMP regulations can result in very serious consequences such as seizure, recall, fines and ultimately imprisonment.

The main aim of GMP is to consistently produce high quality medicines or medical devices that meet the international standards required for responsibly managed healthcare. Processes used in manufacture are carefully controlled, and any changes to the process must be evaluated. Changes that have an impact on the quality of the finished product are also validated as required and checked for compliance and consistency with the product specifications.

GMP requirements are not definitive instructions on how to manufacture specific products. GMP forms a series of general principles that must be observed during manufacturing. When a company is setting up its quality program and manufacturing process, there may be many ways to comply with GMP requirements. It is the company’s responsibility to determine the most effective and efficient quality process. This provides much flexibility, but also requires that the manufacturer interpret the requirements in a manner which makes sense for each individual business.

GMP is sometimes referred to as ‘cGMP’ or ‘Current GMP’ reminding manufacturers that they must employ technologies and systems which are up to date in order to comply with the relevant regulations. Systems and equipment adopted to prevent contamination and errors in the past may be considered less than adequate by current standards.


The Basic Rules of GMP

• Operators must be adequately trained to carry out and document procedures.

• Instructions and procedures should be written in clear and unambiguous language. These instructions are often referred to as ‘SOP’s’ or ‘Standard Operating Procedures’.

• Records must be kept, (manually or by instrumentation), during manufacture which proves that all the steps required by the defined procedures and instructions were taken and that the quantity and quality of the drug was as expected.

GMP is as much about procedures and operator training, as it is about equipment usage.

"GMP is as much about procedures and operator training, as it is about equipment usage."

• Any deviations from the standard procedure found during the keeping of production records must be investigated and documented.

• Records of manufacture (including distribution) that enable the complete history of a batch to be traced must be kept and retained in a comprehensible and readily accessible form.

• Care must be taken to ensure the distribution of the drugs minimizes any risk to their quality.

• A system must be in place for recalling any batch of drug from sale or supply.

• Complaints about marketed drugs must be examined and the causes of quality defects investigated.

• Appropriate measures must be taken with respect to the recall of defective drugs to prevent any future recurrence.


Equipment Design and Manufacture

GMP also applies to the design and manufacture of process equipment. Although this area of GMP is not strictly covered by legislation, it is the responsibility of the equipment manufacturer to understand the importance of hygienic design and the training of competent staff to design and construct equipment that meets the specific needs of the end user and comply with GMP requirements. Documentation also has to be provided to give evidence of competence and materials used in construction.

GMP also applies to equipment manufacture

"GMP also applies to equipment manufacture"

The following points should be considered in the design and construction of process equipment intended for use in GMP regulated industries;

• Design must avoid where possible ledges, dirt traps and flat surfaces where excess dust layers can build up.

• All equipment should be easy to clean and ideally be dismantled without the use of tools.

• Materials of construction must meet the required specification and evidence of materials used should be available. In some cases thorough traceability may be required through mill certificates or other means of identification.

In general most end users will provide a detailed specification or URS (user requirement specification) which will provide in detail the exact requirements in terms of materials, surface finishes and material certification. Competency of the manufacturers ability is also often required which may include evidence of a recognised quality system and proof of staff competency for areas such as design, welding, electrical and other areas of equipment construction.

Hopefully this has helped to shed some light on GMP. If you have any questions whatsoever, I would be delighted to answer them.


Colin Ellis

About the Author

Colin Ellis is the Managing Director of Hanningfield. He has over 30 years experience in the process industries.

Prior to founding Hanningfield in 1987, Colin worked as an engineer for Smith and Nephew, May and Baker and GlaxoSmithKline.

E-Mail: colin@hanningfield.com

Pharmaceutical Powder Loading

The loading of machines with powder can be a complicated and troublesome process.

The biggest issue is nearly always containment. How do you ensure that no powder is leaked or lost during the transfer?

A common problem occurs during the loading of tablet presses, granulators, high-shear mixer, capsule filling machines etc. Often these are loaded from IBCs in the room above the process room. The difficult part is ensuring the powder transfers from the IBC to the machine without any mishaps.  There are a number of ways to achieve a solution including utilising a rotary valve for controlling the flow of powder, or an interlock system between feed chute and IBC outlet.

An alternative problem maybe loading a machine that is on the same floor as the IBC.  How do you transfer the powder from the IBC, into the machine, without spilling or losing powder? In this scenario vacuum transfer is an excellent method of overcoming this problem.

Hanningfield have more than 20 years experience in pharmaceutical processing and have helped numerous manufacturers to solve this problem.  All our equipment is manufactured by ourselves in the United Kingdom. Although each application is different, each objective is the same - to load powder into the machine without any issues.

For more information on how to solve this problem, please just contact us.


Hanningfield on Front Page of EPM Magazine

Hanningfield are pleased to be on the front page of the January/February edition of EPM Magazine.  Hanningfield are prominently featured on the front page of the magazine, with an article about the Uni-Dust cyclone, and how it can be used to collect excess tablet press powder.


To see the editorial simply click the image above, or click here.

Tag Cloud